Governing with the Charter
336 pages, 6 x 9
Paperback
Release Date:04 Oct 2006
ISBN:9780774812122
Hardcover
Release Date:11 Aug 2005
ISBN:9780774812115
PDF
Release Date:01 May 2006
ISBN:9780774851718
GO TO CART

Governing with the Charter

Legislative and Judicial Activism and Framers' Intent

SERIES: Law and Society
UBC Press

Since the introduction of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982, the question of judicial power and its relationship to parliamentary democracy has been an important one in Canadian politics. Some critics, suspicious of what they perceive as the "activism" of "unelected and unaccountable" judges, view the increased power of the Supreme Court as a direct challenge to parliament. But has parliamentary democracy been weakened by judicial responses to the Charter?

In Governing with the Charter, James Kelly clearly demonstrates that our current democratic deficit is not the result of the Supreme Court’s judicial activism. On the contrary, an activist framers’ intent surrounds the Charter, and the Supreme Court has simply, and appropriately, responded to this new constitutional environment. While the Supreme Court is admittedly a political actor, it is not the sole interpreter of the Charter, as the court, the cabinet, and bureaucracy all respond to the document, which has ensured the proper functioning of constitutional supremacy in Canada.

Kelly analyzes the parliamentary hearings on the Charter and also draws from interviews with public servants, senators, and members of parliament actively involved in appraising legislation to ensure that it is consistent with the Charter. He concludes that the principal institutional outcome of the Charter has been a marginalization of Parliament and that this is due to the Prime Minister’s decision on how to govern with the Charter.

A significant contribution to law and society studies, Governing with the Charter will be widely read by political scientists, legal scholars, parliamentarians, public servants, and students of the machinery of government.

Awards

  • 2005, Short-listed - Donner Prize, Donner Foundation
Governing With the Charter offers a number of challenging insights into the new era of Canadian politics. The theory of multiple rights activism, the historical analysis of framers’ intent, the reconceptualization of judicial activism, and the normative implications for the future make this a most satisfying volume for the scholar of Canadian law, as well as for the general comparative courts researcher. David L. Weiden, Law and Politics Book Review, vol. 16, no. 6
Perhaps the best single attempt at explaining Charter litigation and politics. It puts the debate over the Charter, Supreme Court, and parliamentary supremacy in a refreshingly new light, using not only some clear thinking about the problem but also, new information. Roy B. Flemming, Professor of Political Science, Texas A&M University, author of Tournament of Appeals: Granting Judicial Review in Canada
James B. Kelly is Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at Concordia University.

Acknowledgments

Acronyms

Introduction

Part 1: Democratic Activism and Constitutional Politics

1 Democracy and Judicial Review

2 Constitutional Politics and the Charter

3 Framers’ Intent and the Parliamentary Arena

Part 2: Judicial Activism and the Supreme Court of Canada

4 The Supreme Court and Police Conduct

5 Guardians of the Constitution

Part 3: Legislative Activism and the Policy Process

6 The Charter and Canadian Federalism

7 Governing with the Charter of Rights

Conclusion

Bibliography

Index

Free Shipping   Blue
Find what you’re looking for...
Stay Informed

Receive the latest UBC Press news, including events, catalogues, and announcements.


Read past newsletters
Current Catalogue
Catalogue Fall 2018 Cover Canadian
Publishers Represented
UBC Press is the Canadian agent for several international publishers. Visit our Publishers Represented page to learn more.