Moved by the State

Forced Relocation and Making a Good Life in Postwar Canada

By Tina Loo

SERIES: Brenda and David McLean Canadian Studies

UBC Press

“Why don’t they just move?” This reductive question is asked whenever reports surface of the all-too-common lack of social services and economic opportunities in Canada’s rural and urban communities. But why are certain people and places vulnerable? Who is responsible for remedying the situation? And what is fair?

From the 1950s to the 1970s, the Canadian government relocated people, often against their will, in order to improve their lives. Moved by the State offers a completely new interpretation of this undertaking, seeing it as part of a larger project of economic development and poverty alleviation. This finely crafted history therefore focuses on the bureaucrats and academics who designed, implemented, and monitored the forced relocations, rather than on the experience of those who were uprooted.

Tina Loo explores the contradiction between intention and consequence as resettlement played out among Inuit in the central Arctic, fishing families in Newfoundland’s outports, farmers and loggers in Quebec’s Gaspé region, Black residents of Halifax’s Africville, and Chinese Canadians in Vancouver’s East Side. In the process, she reveals the optimistic belief underpinning postwar relocations: the power of the interventionist state to do good.

This book invites the attention of scholars and students of Canadian social and political history, and will also appeal to general readers interested in postwar Canada, the welfare state, and community, regional, and international development.

Awards

2020, Shortlisted - Best Scholarly Book in Canadian History, Canadian Historical Association
2020, Shortlisted - J.W. Dafoe Book Prize, J.W. Dafoe Foundation
2020, Winner - Best Book in Political History, Canadian Historical Association

RELATED TOPICS: Canadian History, Canadian Studies, History, Social History

…the book is thought-provoking and will inspire discussion among those looking to Canadian social and political challenges of the past, as well as those considering them in the future. C. J. Taylor, Parks Canada, Prairie History

Moved by the State illuminates a moment in Canadian history when bureaucrats, politicians, and university ‘experts’ – imbued with hope and a belief in the interventionist state – planned the forcible relocation of individuals from their communities in order to help them share in ‘the good life.’ It is meticulously researched, theoretically informed, and convincingly argued. James Kenny, associate professor, Department of History, Royal Military College of Canada

Tina Loo is a masterful scholar and in Moved by the State she offers a completely new interpretation of resettlements of the 1950s and ’60s as understood through the lens of high modernism. The result is both revisionist and refreshing. Penny Bryden, author of Canada: A Political Biography

Tina Loo is a professor of history at the University of British Columbia. Her previous book is States of Nature: Conserving Canada’s Wildlife in the Twentieth Century. A recipient of Clio and Sir John A. Macdonald prizes from the Canadian Historical Association, as well as the Canada Prize from the Canadian Federation of Humanities and Social Sciences, she is also a member of the Royal Society of Canada.

Introduction

1 “No More Canadians Will Starve!”: Development, Discipline, and Decolonizing the North

2 “The Governmentality Game”: Problematizing, Resettling, and Democratizing Newfoundland

3 “Artisans of Their Destiny”: Participation, Power, and Place in Quebec’s Backcountry

4 “Deviating from the Strict Letter of the Law”: Race, Poverty, and Planning in Postwar Halifax

5 “A Fourth Level of Government”? Urban Renewal, State Power, and Democracy in Vancouver’s East Side

Conclusion

Notes; Bibliography; Index

Related Titles